Misdirected Mark Forums

Let's do Dungeon World

Oh. Wait. It's Basic D&D

Those are really cool Jared. There's only one thing that would need an alteration which is the commune spell. The reason is there's nothing outside the world Avalon is on. Just endless void and the terrible entities that want to and have destroyed everything else so any extra planar entities would b...

It’s the problem with trying to un-PbtA a game to an OSR styled game. If we don’t know what parts we’re trying to design into it we don’t really know where to go. I suppose the first thing to do would be to figure out which parts of non-PbtA games are we looking to put into a game to make it that ga...

There are a lot of bad dnd introductions that don’t give players enough direction, especially when the adventure assumes players are going to do x. There are also a lot of bad Call of Cthulhu, Star Wars, and insert game system that have bad introductions for their adventures. There might not be a on...

The 3-18 spread made a lot more sense when there was a rule for, “If you want to do x then roll under your stat on a d20. That’s in 1st edition or basic, one of those two rule sets. It also mattered a lot more when rolling for stats was the intended part of the game because the average was 10-11. Th...

What I meant is just assign damage to the ability score modifier. In dnd, as it’s constructed, the only part of the stat that matters in the vast majority of situations is the modifier so just damage the modifier. Isn’t your long jump idea exactly what I said. Have a static number and then something...

This weeks topic for chatter is give us your best leading question. Not only do we want to hear them but we will answer some of our favorites on the next episode of MMP.

Tomorrow it all begins.

I do enjoy this game when I’m looking to play a strategy game for around 20 minutes.

Which parts of the OSR styled games are you looking to emulate in a PbtA styled game?